
“Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard.” —H.L. Mencken
When Santa Barbara Mayor-elect Kristen Sneddon takes up the gavel in January, she’ll preside over a reconstituted City Council that might be mistaken for a meeting of the County Democratic Central Committee.
Amid the spectacle of touchdown dances and triumphalism by victorious progressives, however, there were plenty of other political performances worthy of note.
The envelope please…
Most Valuable Surrogate
Winner: Laura Capps. Persevering with county business even as she prepared for, and starred in, multiple celebrations of her high-spirited wedding, the Second District supervisor used her third hand to help steady Sneddon’s wobbling operation at a pivotal moment in the campaign. After Team Kristen was rocked by its failure to secure expected endorsements from erstwhile supporters Dem Women, the Women’s Political Committee and the SB Independent, Laura jumped in as an attack dog, excoriating Friedman’s big-bucks real estate contributions and enlisting allies in what became a sustained offensive that stalled Eric and reversed the momentum of the race.
Loser: Salud Carbajal. A week before Labor Day, Santa Barbara’s Man in Washington shook up the mayor’s race, defying the Democratic Party’s endorsement of Sneddon and choosing personal friendship over partisan loyalty to throw his weight behind former longtime aide Friedman. After the shocking announcement, there wasn’t much of a second act to Carbajal’s dramatic move, however, save for a couple of mailers, some fundraising calls and a few joint visits to State Street patisseries where Salud could fill his pie hole, as Eric’s painful loss left the congressman’s influence arrow on his home turf pointing sharply down.
Most Valuable Coalition
Winner: Left-Wing Activists. The county Democratic Party and its organizers earned major, much-deserved props for the field operation that was key to the SB-centric blue wave it engineered. But staffers and volunteers from an alliance of interlocking and overlapping lefty groups — from the Tenants Union, CAUSE, Strong Towns and Democratic Socialists to the Sierra Club, Planned Parenthood, immigrant rights outfits and SEIU — also played a key part in the City Hall sweep led by Sneddon.
Loser: Business Moderates. Business groups, from the California Association of Realtors and the South Coast Chamber, to multiple downtown commercial property owners, combined to give Eric a huge cash advantage over Kristen. He also won significant support from building trades unions but in the end wound up with far more dollars than votes, as the campaign asset of money proved less valuable than the robust on-the-ground organization backing her.
Most Valuable News Subject
Winner: Devon Wardlow. The city planning commissioner and erstwhile pot lobbyist possesses a personality and lived experience worthy of a Tolstoy novel, and emerged as something of a political Rorschach test in the media and on the campaign trail. On her way to winning the District 4 council race, Devon inspired helicopter-parent levels of protectiveness and indulgence from fervent supporters, in equal measure with antagonism and antipathy from champions of her opponents, who viewed her as a symbol of what’s wrong with insider city politics.
Loser: Jason Dominguez. After losing a council re-election bid in the Eastside’s District 1 a few years ago, Jason moved his young family to the Upper East neighborhood and transmogrified into a more mature and mellow candidate for the District 4 seat in 2026. Dominguez seemed poised to orchestrate an intriguing comeback arc before he … did nothing … in pursuit of his would-be restoration, putting forth a low-energy and poorly funded effort that predictably notched him a dismal fourth-place finish in a field of four in the 4th.
Most Valuable Rookie
Winner (tie): Monte Wilson and Genevieve Taft-Vazquez. If at-large council elections were still a thing, it’s not unlikely that the top three finishers would all have come out of District 4, where retired IT exec Wilson and corporate consultant Taft-Vazquez both flashed as high-quality candidates of the old school. Monte and Genevieve have achieved much with careers and families, but their sincere desire to give back to the community by sharing real-life experience and hard-won wisdom at City Hall got flattened by the Dem district elections machine and the sharp elbows of a candidate jostling onto the crowded track to local political advancement.
Loser: Cevin Cathell. As a rationale for candidacy, “A lot of people told me I should run” is neither a serious reason to enter a political race nor a compelling message to voters, but movie producer Cevin unfortunately never moved much past it. A smiling, friendly face on the trail, Cathell’s sunny nature kept her from drawing contrasts with chief rival and favorite Ian Baucke, and her reluctance to take on the flawed front-runner ended in an election-night stomping in a race she ostensibly could have won.
Most Valuable Proletarian
Winner: James Zurlinden. A blue-collar vibe guy who spent 15 years working his way up from line cook to head chef, Zurlinden pursued a quixotic one-man crusade for council in District 5 that fell short, but was laudable for its thoughtful perspective. Here’s hoping he stays with it and wins appointment to a city board or commission, since his workingman’s views and hospitality industry sensibility would be welcome at City Hall, which is short on both.
Loser: Ian Baucke. We spit-laughed our coffee while reading a post-election yarn describing the District 5 winner as a tribune of the “working class.” A 27-year old City Hall nepo baby with a D.C. elite education, Ian holds a patronage job in Sen. Monique Limón’s office, which he’s seemed intent on keeping, the better to double-dip at the public trough when his $97,000 council member’s pay and benefit package kicks in.
Most Valuable Operative
Winner: Christian Alonso. Low-key, calm and double-smart, the chair of the Democratic Party orchestrated a countywide sweep of three dozen local government offices by Dem-endorsed candidates while laboring at a full-time tech job teaching AI how to replace him. In his spare time, he dealt with the media in a thoroughly professional manner and played personal therapist, tending to the insecurities of some of the divas and divos on his slate card.
Loser: Bobbi McGinnis. Sure, the Trump-era Republican Party brand is toxic to many Santa Barbara County voters, but chair McGinnis seems to have given up on trying to build the party by attracting moderates, let alone making a case to No Party Preference types. The GOP website says they “recruit for local elected seats,” but they found exactly one candidate to back for four seats in Santa Barbara, and Bob Smith, their candidate for Congress, got so fed up he renounced the endorsement to campaign as an independent.
Most Valuable Independent Expenditure Committee
Winner: Friends of CAUSE Action Fund. The dollar amount that the political action committee for the regional tenant rights outfit pitched into Sneddon’s coffers — $2,581 — was certainly modest, but the purpose for which it was earmarked, helping build out the crucial ground campaign that was essential to the victories of her and liberal allies countywide, brought a whopping return on investment.
Loser: Better Santa Barbara. Kudos to the South Coast Chamber of Commerce for stepping up for business interests in a campaign that seemed mostly indifferent to their concerns, but the tens of thousands they forked out for Friedman and other moderates paid for text chains, mailers and other channels of communication that simply couldn’t match the impact of the lefty coalition’s grind-it-out field operation.
Most Valuable Endorsement
Winner: Santa Barbara Independent. The Indy took a lot of heat from the liberal establishment for picking Eric over Kristen, but a pox on the conspiracy theorists who falsely charged they did it to please real estate advertisers, and good on Marianne Partridge and her staff for spending hours interviewing wannabes and wrestling with the choices. They forswore the easy path of endorsing the liberal odds-on favorite, and stood up to the flak because they thought the other guy would be a better mayor.
Loser: Santa Barbara Police Officers Association. Time was when the POA’s endorsement was a crown jewel for any city campaign, but its political influence has wilted in recent decades and now ranks far behind that of the city firefighters. After behind-the-scenes political machinations, the latter backed all the winners this time out, while the cops went 0-for-4.
Most Valuable Senator-in-Waiting
Winner: Gregg Hart. Monique Limón has just two years left in her state Senate term, and the race to succeed her may not draw much of a crowd if Hart, just re-elected to a third term in the Assembly with two-thirds of the vote, surprises exactly no one by big-footing the contest. That would leave his Assembly seat a hotbed of local 2028 campaigning, as friends of top Hart aide Ethan Bertrand spread the word that he’ll try to replace the boss, and a cast of thousands limbers up to compete.
Loser: Das Williams. We had to laugh at an emailed invitation to a campaign-season event listing among its sponsors “The Honorable Das Williams” — honorable to who exactly, we wondered. Newsmakers later found that he’s rolled over leftover money from his old Board of Supervisors committee into a 2028 campaign account - purportedly to run for Dem County Committee, of all things — suggesting some Napoleon-at-Elba comeback plotting, just two years after he suffered a humiliating defeat for the ages by losing his seat to Roy Lee.
Most Valuable Election Watch Party
Winner: KEYT. Linear television is dying only slightly slower than the print newspaper industry, but the local channel’s newsroom is still the most entertaining place for a political junkie to hang out on election night. It’s a rare, non-wildfire opportunity for the station to show off the full size and scope of its reporting corps, with correspondents deployed at campaign parties countywide and seasoned anchors with deep community roots like Beth Farnsworth, Scott Hennessee and C.J. Ward emceeing the show. Plus: newsroom pizza and donuts.
Honorable mention: newspress.com. The News-Press devised a state-of-the-art, breaking election news feature for their site that instantly became the best online source to monitor returns. It put them in position to authoritatively call races and many candidates shared it on their social media.
Loser: Dem Women. Not long ago the Democratic Women of Santa Barbara club stood fiercely independent and at arm’s length from the county committee, but on Election Night it looked a bit like a vassal state, forgoing its own party to roister with Dem central in the name of “unity.” The decision chafed some members, as it raised the temperature on already simmering conflicts over endorsements for the mayor’s race and District 4, after the group couldn’t agree on who to back in those hotly contested campaigns.
Most Valuable Mom
Winner (tie): Carol Warner and Celeste Barber. Kristen and Eric were both raised by tough, smart mothers who brought them up with compassionate and communitarian values that led both to pursue public service. Carol and Celeste were both fixtures on the campaign trail, showing up to root for their favorite candidate at countless debates, forums and community gatherings throughout the long campaign, so Newsmakers wants to say - you raised them right.
Loser: None.
Image: cityandstatepa.com.

